by Simon Wilde
There
will be minor explosions of righteous indignation around Australia,
and in the Shane Warne household in Hampshire, at the news that
Muttiah Muralitharan has broken the world record for highest number
of Test wickets in November later this year. And for once, it
is hard to disagree with our friends in the southern hemisphere.
Australians
may not be right to dismiss all Murali’s works on the grounds
that his action is illegal; under the latest definition of what
constitutes a "throw" it definitely is not.
But
they do have a case for saying the Sri Lankan’s record does
not bear worthy comparison with that of Warne, who retired in
January with 708 victims to his name, because of the many easy
pickings he has garnered from the duffers of Bangladesh and Zimbabwe.
Many of the recent games involving these two countries have been
Test matches only in name. Bangladesh lose nearly 60% of their
Tests by an innings, while Zimbabwe have lost 13 of their past
25 Tests by the same margin. These aren’t contests, they
are carnage. And no bowler has benefited to quite the extent that
Murali has.
His
12 wickets in Kandy take his haul in 10 Tests against Bangladesh
to 76, while his tally in 14 games against Zimbabwe is 87. This
means that of his 700 wickets, 163 - or 23% - have come against
this axis of weevils. This is not, of course, Murali’s fault.
He can only bamboozle those who are put before him. But as it
happens Sri Lanka have played both Bangladesh and Zimbabwe more
often than any other major team and as a result their players
have enjoyed many luxuriant days.
All
this distorts the records and makes meaningful comparisons very
difficult. Warne, for instance, made only three Test appearances
against Bangladesh and Zimbabwe and took only 17 wickets. It might
also be worth pointing out that against the two teams that arguably
play spin bowling best, Murali’s record is no more than
adequate: 55 wickets at 31.4 apiece against Australia, 67 wickets
at 32.5 each against India.
Murali,
of course, is not alone. Kumar Sangakkara, his teammate, has just
helped himself to back-to-back double-centuries against Bangladesh
and three years ago took 270 off a miserably weak Zimbabwe attack.
Then
there is Sachin Tendulkar, who averages 92.1 against Zimbabwe
and Bangladesh, and Mohammad Yousuf, Pakistan’s tireless
runmaker, who averages an even cooler 101.7 against these opponents.
Small
beer, still, compared to Jacques Kallis, who averages 223.3 against
the minnows, or Steve Waugh, who took them for 546 runs for twice
out. How these players would no doubt like us all not to mention
such things and reflect instead on their Test averages nestling
comfortably above 50.
Further
insult awaits the Australians. Murali’s next Test series
is in their country in November, where they will do well in two
matches to prevent him claiming the nine wickets he needs to topple
Warne from his perch.
Sweet
revenge for Murali, though, after all the Antipodean insults of
the past.
|