|
By Geoff Robinson
 |
| Mr
Bracks retires as Victoria's second-longest serving premier.
(AFP: Anoek de Groot) |
When
Steve Bracks became Victorian Labor leader in February 1999, replacing
the struggling John Brumby, he took over a party that despaired
of the political ascendancy of Liberal premier Jeff Kennett.
Eight
years later Mr Bracks retires as Victoria's second-longest serving
premier and with a record of extraordinary political success.
Kevin Rudd will hope that his eventual political obituary is comparable.
The
young Bracks was one of the many who joined the ALP in 1975 in
response to the dismissal of the Whitlam government. He did the
hard yards as an ordinary branch member, country schoolteacher
and three times unsuccessful Labor candidate. Not until 1989 did
he leave his home town of Ballarat for a position with the state
Labor government of John Cain. His experience of Victorian Labor's
crisis-ridden final years in government confirmed his conviction
that political success required caution and realism.
In
the 1999 state election campaign Bracks set a template for future
Labor campaigns; he built on the commitment to fiscal conservatism
of his predecessor John Brumby, and focused not on Kennett's controversial
personality but on key areas where the government was vulnerable:
basic services and the neglect of country Victoria.
The
election result stunned many observers. Suburban marginal seats
stuck with Kennett but a backlash against the Government in provincial
cities left three independents, two of whom were definitely not
Labor sympathisers, with the balance of power.
In
the days following the result, Mr Bracks demonstrated exceptional
political skill to win over the independents, enabling Labor to
take government. If Kevin Rudd wins the upcoming federal election
he will face a similar challenge in negotiations with conservatives
such as Barnaby Joyce and Stephen Fielding in the Senate.
Ordinary populism
When
Labor took office in October 1999 it induced relief rather than
euphoria among the Victorian labour movement which was battered
by the Kennett experience. This sense of relief gave Mr Bracks
room to manoeuvre just as Mr Rudd will have if elected prime minister.
The
Bracks government's fiscal conservatism annoyed some of the left
but reassured business and would win over the suburban voters
that stuck with Kennett in 1999.
Mr
Bracks came to exemplify 'ordinary populism', like the Victorian
Bob Hawke, rather the divisive and dynamic style of Jeff Kennett,
Paul Keating or Mark Latham.
Mr
Bracks carefully followed public opinion. His defence of heavy-handed
police tactics during the September 2000 protests against the
World Economic Forum annoyed many in the broader left, just as
Mr Rudd's recent reluctance to criticise the Federal Government
over the Haneef case has been unpopular with civil libertarians.
Overall
however Mr Bracks, like Mr Rudd recently, was able to dominate
the Labor Party. The governments of John Cain and Joan Kirner
had had frequently found themselves at odds with Labor Party conferences
but the ALP left was now splintered and divided, with many former
members in the Greens.
Conservative
control of the Legislative council was a useful alibi for the
Government against its party critics, as the Senate may be for
Kevin Rudd. Unlike Tony Blair or Kevin Rudd, Mr Bracks was conciliatory
towards the broader labour movement; even militant unions were
pleased with his resistance to the Howard Government's industrial
relations policies.
Transparency promised
In
2002 Labor swept to a landslide victory and secured control of
the Legislative Council. In opposition, Mr Bracks and Labor had
denounced Mr Kennett's dictatorial style and promised a new order
of accountability, equity and transparency.
But
in office Labor had lagged on these commitments, government secrecy
remained excessive and gambling revenues continued to prop up
state coffers.
Yet
Labor's post-2002 constitutional reforms kept faith with its promises.
In 2003 the Legislative Council was dramatically reformed, its
power to block supply was removed and proportional representation
introduced.
Like
Tony Blair, Mr Bracks was a constitutional radical. For many on
the broader left the reforms offered the prospect of the Greens
holding the balance of power and pulling Labor to the left, but
these hopes were dashed by the 2006 election. Labor was returned
with only a slightly reduced majority and in the Council controversial
Labor preference deals deprived the Greens of the balance of power.
If
Mr Kennett and Mr Keating sought to spur on social changes and
John Howard to resist them, Mr Bracks's approach has been to go
with the flow of events whilst cautiously steering policy towards
the left.
In
his last two years as premier he showed a more reformist streak.
Voters had now forgotten the budgetary crises of the early 1990s
and Labor's recent budgets have been bolder, a state bill of rights
came in 2006 and abortion law reform seems likely.
Mr
Bracks was not always able to escape the arrogance that comes
with successful political leadership and for a long time his government
dwelt in the shadows of its predecessors. But in many aspects
he has pioneered the contemporary model of Labor leadership, which
both John Brumby as his apparent likely successor, and Kevin Rudd,
if elected PM later this year, will follow in his surprisingly
large political footsteps.
Geoff
Robinson is a lecturer in politics at Deakin University.
|